
The New York City Council voted 44-5 on Thursday, November 12, for a bill that bars retailers and other businesses from using customers’ personal data to charge different people different prices for the same product. The Record reports that the city’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection could fine companies up to $1,000 per violation. The bill, Introduction 891-A, sponsored by Council Speaker Julie Menin, still has to become law. City & State reports it would take effect one year after that, and that Mayor Zohran Mamdani voiced support for it.
“Surveillance pricing” means setting a price based on what a company has inferred about you, such as your search history, browsing behavior or purchase habits. The council’s own press release describes it as invisible to shoppers and says reports suggest it occurs in a variety of industries. It cites an investigation that found a grocery delivery platform’s pricing experiments produced individualized price differences as high as 23 percent, and another that found a television’s price rose from $499.99 to $599.99 when the customer pulled into the store’s parking lot. The Record adds that evidence of how widespread the practice is remains limited, even as grocery stores, ride-share companies and airlines are suspected of using it. Companies including Uber have pushed back on the bill, City & State reports, and Menin rejected the argument that it would stop them from offering discounts.
The bill allows “bona fide discounts and rewards that are legitimate and transparent,” according to the council release, from buy-one-get-one-free deals and loyalty programs to student and veteran discounts. City & State adds that it includes a corrective-action provision to help small businesses avoid fines if they fix violations promptly.
The Record and City & State count the city’s place differently. The Record calls New York the second U.S. city to pass such a ban, after Seattle, where a similar ban was signed last month, and says New Jersey, Connecticut and Maryland already have similar laws on the books. City & State calls it the fifth jurisdiction in the country with a ban. At the state level, a similar bill passed the legislature in June and, per The Record, has sat unsigned on Gov. Kathy Hochul’s desk for several months; advocates quoted by The Record worry she could use an unusual New York power to amend passed bills and weaken it. Separately, The Record reports the Federal Trade Commission ordered nine food delivery, airline, ride-sharing and retail companies in October to answer questions about how they use personal data to set prices.
